Belgium as dinosaur country
PLANET BELGIUM
Part 4: A swamp full of drowned iguanodons
125 million years ago, herds of iguanodons roamed our region, including the water-filled sinkholes of Hainaut. Many dozens of these thirsty four-tonne creatures would become trapped in one of them and suffocate. Their drowning deaths became our palaeontological fortune: their remains fossilised perfectly and slid through the unstable subsurface down into the deeper coal layers of the Carboniferous. There, in 1878, two miners struck the first bones. The Iguanodons of Bernissart became the Rosetta Stone of the fledgling science of dinosaur palaeontology. The evolution and way of life of the dinosaurs has been unravelled in the century and a half since: from their modest beginnings in the Triassic, through their soaring heights in the Jurassic, until an asteroid at the end of the Cretaceous, 66 million years ago, brought their reign to an end. But a handful of feathered species flew through the apocalypse.
Reinout Verbeke
PLANET BELGIUM,
the odyssey of our country
Our patch of land in the heart of Europe has been on an eventful journey that has taken around five hundred million years. A long time before it actually existed as a country, Belgium started out near the South Pole, crossed the equator and has docked – for the time being at least – in the Northern Hemisphere.
It was a voyage full of dramatic collisions that have made our country a geological El Dorado. Let's hitch a ride with geologists, palaeontologists and citizen scientists as they reconstruct the landscape and the life that once swam, crawled or flew in it. Get ready to go on the most in-depth journey through our country, in five parts. This is part four.
Time is unfathomably deep. Earth scientists try to get a grip on it by dividing it into 'periods'. In this series, we have already passed through the Cambrian, Ordovician, Devonian and Carboniferous. Within those periods, geologists and palaeontologists do the finer work: defining 'epochs', such as the Upper Devonian, and 'ages', such as the Famennian. But they also zoom out and group periods together by asking: what is their greatest common denominator? These are the 'eras', spanning many tens to hundreds of millions of years. At the boundaries of eras lie major turning points in geology — and these almost always coincide with a mass extinction.
In this fourth episode of Planet Belgium, we have reached the end of one such 'era' or 'major epoch': the Palaeozoic. Literally: ‘the time of ancient life’. We are stepping into the Mesozoic, ‘the era of middle life’. New players have appeared on the stage, and they will become dominant in this era: the reptiles. Think dinosaurs, mosasaurs and pterosaurs. On land, at sea and in the air, respectively, they become unavoidable.
But their dominance did not come about overnight. For that, we must go back to two P's: the Permian and Pangaea.
Pangaea was the gigantic continent that formed at the transition from the Carboniferous to the Permian, roughly 300 million years ago. It was a mighty collision: the supercontinent Gondwana (think Africa plus South America plus Antarctica plus Australia) crashing into its northern counterpart Laurussia (North America and Europe). Bang! — though continents collide in slow motion, centimetre by centimetre, over tens of millions of years. With Pangaea, all landmasses were united, surrounded by a single ocean, Panthalassa. Note for later: the next time the whole world comes together will be in roughly 250 million years.
270 million years ago. The world has been driven together into Pangaea (light blue strips included). (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
270 million years ago. The world has been driven together into Pangaea (light blue strips included). (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
At the collision zone between Gondwana and Laurussia, roughly straddling the equator, a long mountain range arose. It ran from the Appalachians across several well-known European ranges (the Massif Central, the Vosges, the Eifel, the Harz…) all the way to the Urals. This is the Variscan mountain belt. In our region, the Ardennes rose high (far higher than the gentle hills they are today), while Flanders remained relatively unaffected.
All the world's landmass together is cosy, but it also has consequences — especially for areas no longer bordering an ocean, like ours. Clouds deposit their rain closer to continental margins, so the near-endless interior of Pangaea dries out. And the Ardennes and other ranges to our south blocked moist oceanic air. Our boggy, lush forests of the Carboniferous, full of towering scale trees (episode 3), became desert with sand dunes. Who would have thought our rainy little country was once the Sahara?
Another, older name for Pangaea is the 'New Red Continent', by analogy with the 'Old Red Continent' from the Early Devonian (episode 2). The red colour comes from the iron minerals in the sand oxidising. On my desk lies a piece of light-red sandstone from a quarry in Vielsalm, picked up during a field trip because I found it beautiful. Now I realise how remarkable it is — because from the Permian (299 to 252 million years ago), erosion has left very few traces in our country. Of virtually every other period in the past five hundred million years, we do have fine outcrops, especially in Wallonia.
During the Permian, Belgium was a Sahara. This sandstone from the area around Vielsalm bears witness to that. Due to the heat and drought, the iron in the sandstone oxidised, turning it red. (Photo: Thierry Hubin)
During the Permian, Belgium was a Sahara. This sandstone from the area around Vielsalm bears witness to that. Due to the heat and drought, the iron in the sandstone oxidised, turning it red. (Photo: Thierry Hubin)
Early Reptiles and Mammals
Against the bone-dry world of the early Pangaea, some vertebrates were already quite well equipped since the Carboniferous. We call them amniotes. They are the ancestors of all reptiles, birds and mammals alike. They evolved from amphibious four-limbed animals whose fins were strong enough to haul themselves out of the water, and whose swim bladders had transformed into lungs. Those amphibians still had to return to the water to lay their eggs.
Amniotes found a solution. They created a comfortable miniature pond inside the egg. How? Through a series of membranes: the amnion, the yolk sac, the allantois and the chorion. The amnion is the amniotic sac in which the embryo develops. From the ventral side of the embryo spring the yolk sac, containing food reserves, and the allantois, the waste sac. The three sacs sit within a protective membrane, the chorion. Around that chorion comes either a soft, leathery shell or a harder one made of calcium.
A chicken egg as an example: the embryo sits in an amniotic sac (amnion) and is connected to a yolk sac (vitellus) and a waste sac (allantois). Around these are a protective membrane (chorion), egg white (albumen) and an eggshell. (Image: KDS4444, Wikimedia Commons)
A chicken egg as an example: the embryo sits in an amniotic sac (amnion) and is connected to a yolk sac (vitellus) and a waste sac (allantois). Around these are a protective membrane (chorion), egg white (albumen) and an eggshell. (Image: KDS4444, Wikimedia Commons)
Amniotes were the great explorers of their time. They ventured ever further from the water and formed new communities — made possible because other organisms had preceded them in colonising dry land: seed-bearing trees (such as conifers), fungi, arachnids and insects.
The amniotes split into three fundamental groups during the Carboniferous. "For that, you need to look at the skull and count the holes behind the eye socket," says palaeontologist and science communicator Koen Stein. "The so-called temporal openings. Where openings exist, muscles can be better anchored, and a greater bite force develops."
The number of openings behind the eye socket distinguishes anapsids (extinct group, A), synapsids (proto-mammals and mammals, B) and diapsids (reptiles and birds, C) from one another. (Preto(m), Wikimedia Commons)
The number of openings behind the eye socket distinguishes anapsids (extinct group, A), synapsids (proto-mammals and mammals, B) and diapsids (reptiles and birds, C) from one another. (Preto(m), Wikimedia Commons)
"The anapsids have no temple window, and their simple skull most closely resembles that of amphibians. There are no anapsids alive today. The synapsids have one opening, and that group includes mammals. Feel your own temple. But the synapsid group also includes Permian animals like Dimetrodon, with its spectacular sail on the back — it's very hard to grasp that we are relatively closely related to that creature. The third group are the diapsids, with two temple windows. Within them, one subgroup will evolve to include snakes, lizards and the mosasaurs (marine reptiles). Another subgroup will give rise to crocodilians, pterosaurs (flying reptiles) and — yes — the dinosaurs and birds. We call this latter subgroup the archosaurs, literally the 'ruling lizards'." And many of them walked upright, which would prove to be another game changer.
During the Permian, the diapsid reptiles are not yet in charge, and there are no dinosaurs whatsoever. It is the synapsids (one temple window, the lineage of the mammals) that call the shots. They are adapted to the dry regions of Pangaea and refresh themselves at the lakes filled by mega-monsoons. They are the crawling apex predators with a flamboyant back sail, like Dimetrodon. Later in the Permian, they are outcompeted by other bizarre proto-mammals: the gorgonopsians.
Dimetrodon is more closely related to us, mammals, than to reptiles. We are both synapsids: a single temporal opening behind the eye socket. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
Dimetrodon is more closely related to us, mammals, than to reptiles. We are both synapsids: a single temporal opening behind the eye socket. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
Gorgonopsids, sabre-toothed mammal-like synapsids. (H. Zell, Wikimedia Commons)
Gorgonopsids, sabre-toothed mammal-like synapsids. (H. Zell, Wikimedia Commons)
You might describe them as large 'sabre-toothed rats' — slender predators between half a metre and three metres long, with a broad, flattened snout and impressive canine teeth. These they sank into the flesh of other mammal-like creatures, the dicynodonts: stocky herbivores resembling a wild boar with the head of a turtle. These are among the forgotten weirdos of the Permian, which Hollywood has shown little interest in.
In the archosaurs, however… Their kingdom begins after an apocalyptic period. The Great Dying is the largest mass extinction the Earth has ever known. "Most people know about the mass extinction at the end of the Cretaceous, but at the end of the Permian, about 252 million years ago, as many as 95% of marine species and 70% of land species went extinct."
This third of five great mass extinctions did not happen all at once, but in pulses over a period of roughly fifteen million years. Many animal groups could not recover their lost diversity between pulses. In the final two million years of the Permian, what is now Siberia was literally cracking apart. Gigantic quantities of lava poured through fissures in the Earth's crust. The volume of basalt (rapidly cooled magma) in the last million years of the Permian is estimated at four million cubic kilometres. If you were to spread that basalt evenly across Belgium, the layer would be 130 kilometres thick — thirteen times the cruising altitude of a commercial aircraft.
The Great Dying is the largest mass extinction the Earth has ever known
The amount of CO₂ released from the ground during that million years is estimated at 208,000 gigatons — 80 times more than humanity's total emissions since the Industrial Revolution. The eruptions also released sulphur and heavy metals. All of this led to intense warming (in a world already hot), acid rain, ocean acidification and oxygen depletion, a hole in the ozone layer and metal poisoning. The flood basalts of the Siberian Traps draw a thick line: goodbye, Palaeozoic. We shall not see these creatures again (except as fossils): trilobites (which existed for 270 million years), sea scorpions, the corals of the Devonian and Carboniferous, and on land the proto-mammals with their back sails and sabre teeth. The Earth had very nearly wiped the slate clean — but a few survivors were handed a new playing field.
Small sprinting dinos
A traveller to the middle of the Triassic, 230 million years ago, some twenty million years after the greatest mass extinction, would search a long time for dinosaurs. They exist, but they are no bigger than a cat. Koen Stein: "You would, however, encounter plenty of large and fearsome archosaurs. They look as though someone had fitted a crocodile with a T. rex head and asked it to walk upright. The diversity of such crocodilian-like creatures — including the feared Rauisuchia — was enormous in the Triassic. There were even herbivores among them."
Looking at the head alone, you'd think: T. rex! But this is a crocodile-like creature from the Triassic. Saurosuchus walked with its legs beneath its body rather than to the sides. The dinosaurs lived in the shadow of such crocs, but that was about to change... (Fernando de Gorocica, Wikimedia Commons)
Looking at the head alone, you'd think: T. rex! But this is a crocodile-like creature from the Triassic. Saurosuchus walked with its legs beneath its body rather than to the sides. The dinosaurs lived in the shadow of such crocs, but that was about to change... (Fernando de Gorocica, Wikimedia Commons)
The still-small dinosaurs share an important characteristic with those crocodilian archosaur cousins: upright posture. Their forelimbs and hindlimbs sit directly beneath the body, not splayed to the sides like in crocodilians and lizards — cold-blooded crawlers that have no need for speed. The dinosaur femur had a head at the top that fitted perfectly into an open hip socket. This turned the legs into natural load-bearing columns, vastly increasing stability and carrying capacity. With legs beneath your body, you become a sprinter; you can cover greater distances, catch prey more quickly, while expending less energy as your limbs move fluidly. Legs beneath the body is an evolutionary tipping point.
230 million years ago. The first dinosaurs emerge in the Middle Triassic, when the entire world is still joined together as Pangaea. Our regions have long resembled a Sahara, but are now more frequently flooded by the sea. (C. R. Scotese and GPlates)
230 million years ago. The first dinosaurs emerge in the Middle Triassic, when the entire world is still joined together as Pangaea. Our regions have long resembled a Sahara, but are now more frequently flooded by the sea. (C. R. Scotese and GPlates)
In Argentina and Brazil — in the wetter zones of the otherwise dry Pangaea — early Dinosauria from the mid-Triassic have been found since the 1960s, including Herrerasaurus, Eoraptor and Pisanosaurus. The differences between these three would lead to the great split into three clades. Herrerasaurus and its relatives gave rise to the lineage of carnivorous, agile, intelligent predators such as Velociraptor, T. rex and birds — the theropods. Eoraptor and kin are in all likelihood the forerunners of the plant-eating long-necks, the sauropods. And Pisanosaurus, or close relatives, are thought to have led to the lineage including Iguanodon, hadrosaurs (duck-billed dinosaurs), horned dinosaurs like Triceratops, and armoured ones like Stegosaurus and Ankylosaurus.
This last group, the ornithischians, have a pelvis in which the pubic bone is rotated backwards. In theropods and sauropods, it points forward. This division between ornithischians (bird-hipped) and saurischians (lizard-hipped), based on the position of the hip bones, has long been a classic distinction. But today palaeontologists are testing alternative family trees by processing enormous datasets of anatomical characteristics with statistical programmes. The debate about the major branches of the dinosaur family tree is very much alive.
The earliest beginnings of the dinosaurs: small, carnivorous, and sprinting on their hind legs. That last trait was an evolutionary turning point. (Photo: WehaveaTrex, Wikimedia Commons)
The earliest beginnings of the dinosaurs: small, carnivorous, and sprinting on their hind legs. That last trait was an evolutionary turning point. (Photo: WehaveaTrex, Wikimedia Commons)
Did those early dinosaurs also walk here in Belgium? Yes. In a bone bed at Habay-la-Vieille, in the southernmost part of our country near Arlon, dinosaur teeth have been found from the Late Triassic — from all three dinosaur groups: sauropods, theropods and ornithischians.
Around 210 million years ago, dinosaurs had not only become more diverse and numerous, but also larger. "Some had long necks, like Plateosaurus, weighing up to three tonnes. In the Europe of that time, they were as ubiquitous as cows today. They were found in abundance in Germany, France and Switzerland. Every self-respecting natural history museum has a genuine specimen on display. It is from this group that the iconic long-necks of the Jurassic will evolve."
Unveiling of the authentic skeleton of Plateosaurus "Ben", excavated from a quarry in Frick (Switzerland). Plateosaurus was a "prosauropod", a forerunner of the later long-necked sauropods of the Jurassic and Cretaceous. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
Unveiling of the authentic skeleton of Plateosaurus "Ben", excavated from a quarry in Frick (Switzerland). Plateosaurus was a "prosauropod", a forerunner of the later long-necked sauropods of the Jurassic and Cretaceous. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
Great Heights
After another mass extinction — the fourth of five — we enter the Jurassic. This extinction followed the same script as The Great Dying at the end of the Permian: volcanism, volcanism and more volcanism, triggered by the breaking apart of Pangaea. Here it was the very beginning of the Atlantic Ocean: West Africa and North America tearing apart from each other, with even more flood basalt than in Siberia. That must have thrown the climate into serious turmoil.
180 million years ago (Jurassic). A fledgling Atlantic Ocean begins to peek through between West Africa and North America. This brings with it volcanism and climate change. (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
180 million years ago (Jurassic). A fledgling Atlantic Ocean begins to peek through between West Africa and North America. This brings with it volcanism and climate change. (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
160 million years ago (Jurassic). The Atlantic Ocean grows and Laurasia (North America and Eurasia) breaks away from Gondwana (South America and Africa). (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
160 million years ago (Jurassic). The Atlantic Ocean grows and Laurasia (North America and Eurasia) breaks away from Gondwana (South America and Africa). (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
Three-quarters of all species went extinct. Among those that did not survive: the upright-walking crocodilian-like creatures, after which only the crawling and aquatic forms we know today remained. With the crocodilian-like predators gone, nothing stood in the way of the dinosaurs dominating the land.
The Jurassic is the central panel of the triptych that is the Mesozoic — the age of dinosaurs — with the Triassic and Cretaceous as its two wings. On that central panel, a palaeoartist would paint the iconic sauropods or long-necked dinosaurs: Diplodocus, Apatosaurus, Camarasaurus and Brachiosaurus.
One exposed vertebra is enough to let your imagination grasp how a sauropod would have towered over you
Just how enormous those animals could become, I experienced on two excavation missions for the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences in Wyoming, led by palaeontologist Pascal Godefroit. We dug in the world-famous Morrison Formation — a paradise for dinosaur hunters. Koen Stein was there too, and he still remembers those colossal vertebrae and femurs as if it were yesterday. "One exposed vertebra is enough to let your imagination grasp how a sauropod would have towered over you. The mind simply cannot take it in."
Captions in English available.
From hatchlings the size of a hamster, they grew in thirty years into super-giants as large as an aircraft. How could these animals grow into the largest land creatures that ever lived? "With their long necks, they could take in enormous quantities of foliage without having to take a single step. And sauropods had evolved an efficient respiratory system. Many bones of the neck, chest and tail contained hollows in which air sacs were housed. Those sacs filled during inhalation. During exhalation, air from all those sacs flowed into the lungs. They worked like a bellows — more oxygen to keep the metabolism of that mega-body running." Brachiosaurus could weigh more than thirty tonnes — easily six elephants. In the Cretaceous, titanosaurs such as Argentinosaurus would reach fifty tonnes. Work out how many elephants that is. "Their skeleton had to be enormously strong, yet still remain flexible."
From the Jurassic we also know the apex predator Allosaurus — a leaner version of the iconic Late Cretaceous T. rex (the ancestors of T. rex already existed in the Jurassic, but were still relatively small). A near-complete Allosaurus skeleton, on display at the Institute of Natural Sciences since 2019, comes from that same site in Wyoming.
The fact that most of the species mentioned above ring a bell owes as much to popular culture as to a fierce rivalry known as the Bone Wars — between two palaeontologists, Edward Drinker Cope and Othniel Charles Marsh, who used the Morrison Formation as their battlefield. That they sabotaged each other's excavation teams — even using dynamite — is an embarrassing story in the early history of dinosaur palaeontology. But they did describe the bulk of the Jurassic dinosaurs mentioned above, including Stegosaurus and lesser-known species such as Dryosaurus (a small forerunner of Iguanodon).
A few other significant developments in the Jurassic: dinosaurs increasingly developed feathers — think Archaeopteryx and Anchiornis, from the theropod group. Birds would eventually evolve from that group of carnivorous dinosaurs. But palaeontologist Pascal Godefroit described in 2014 Kulindadromeus zabaicalicus, a basal dinosaur with feather-like structures belonging to the other clade — the plant-eating ornithischians. This suggests that at the very root of dinosaur evolution (before the split into theropods and ornithischians), they already had feathers. Feathers were thus widespread among dinosaurs — a standard feature of the basic package, though some species subsequently lost the trait. Fluffy down feathers initially served to regulate body temperature, for camouflage and courtship display, but would evolve into flight feathers, allowing small dinosaurs to glide through the air and ultimately to fly.
Kulindadromeus zabaikalicus, described in 2014 by palaeontologist Pascal Godefroit. Feathers were more the rule than the exception among dinosaurs. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
Kulindadromeus zabaikalicus, described in 2014 by palaeontologist Pascal Godefroit. Feathers were more the rule than the exception among dinosaurs. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
In the oceans and seas of the Jurassic, reptiles had clearly already adapted well to the marine environment (some reptiles did indeed return to the water — mammals would later make the same transition). These include the ichthyosaurs, with their dolphin-shaped bodies and long snouts, and the plesiosaurs, with their long necks. Jurassic strata in Belgium are limited to our southernmost point and to the Roer Valley Graben in the northeast. But on the Jurassic Coast of England at Lyme Regis, fossil collector and palaeontologist Mary Anning found the first complete specimens of those impressive marine reptiles in the early nineteenth century. They can be seen in the Natural History Museum in London. She also found a pterosaur — those flying reptiles were around too.
The first complete skeleton of Plesiosaurus, found by Mary Anning. This 3.5-metre specimen was presented in 1824 at a meeting of the Geological Society of London. The same conference at which the very first dinosaur fossil - a jawbone of Megalosaurus - was shown to the scientific world. The Plesiosaurus skeleton can be seen at the Natural History Museum in London. (Photo: the paleobear, Wikimedia Commons)
The first complete skeleton of Plesiosaurus, found by Mary Anning. This 3.5-metre specimen was presented in 1824 at a meeting of the Geological Society of London. The same conference at which the very first dinosaur fossil - a jawbone of Megalosaurus - was shown to the scientific world. The Plesiosaurus skeleton can be seen at the Natural History Museum in London. (Photo: the paleobear, Wikimedia Commons)
Telegram from Bernissart
The Cretaceous period begins — as it inevitably does — with a climate disruption. Ecosystems were turned completely upside down, though we do not know the exact cause. The diversity of sauropods dropped sharply, and the stegosaurs nearly disappeared. The iguanodontians apparently profited from this and became the dominant herbivores, flanked by ankylosaurs and early horned dinosaurs.
Assembly, between October 1882 and March 1883, of the first complete specimen of an iguanodon from Bernissart (specimen Q, holotype of Iguanodon bernissartensis). Left: museum employee and preparator Félix Sonnet. (Photo: Institute of Natural Sciences)
Assembly, between October 1882 and March 1883, of the first complete specimen of an iguanodon from Bernissart (specimen Q, holotype of Iguanodon bernissartensis). Left: museum employee and preparator Félix Sonnet. (Photo: Institute of Natural Sciences)
Iguanodons are found virtually everywhere in Western Europe, but the Belgian specimens are world-famous. In 1878, at the height of the rush for black gold, miners in the Hainaut village of Bernissart - a stone's throw from the French border - struck the first iguanodon bones. A telegram was dispatched to the Musée Royal d'Histoire Naturelle de Belgique with an urgent request to send preparator Louis De Pauw. It was the starting pistol for an unprecedented and highly successful palaeontological mission that would last three years. Bones from some 45 individuals were brought up, and around 25 skeletons were complete or nearly so. When they were mounted, science and the public of the day were for the first time given a complete picture of what a dinosaur looked like.
"Our iguanodons were the Rosetta Stone of dinosaur palaeontology," says Pascal Godefroit, who in 2023 published a landmark work on the Iguanodons. "And although Iguanodon as a species had already been described by Gideon Mantell in 1825, the discovery at Bernissart gave us far greater insight into how those animals lived.
It also gave us a window onto the local ecosystem of 125 million years ago. We had two iguanodontian species — Iguanodon bernissartensis and a smaller, more slender species currently under renewed scrutiny, which may have been unique to the Bernissart region. We also found a toe bone from a carnivorous dinosaur." And in a clay pit near Bernissart, a tibia from a long-necked dinosaur was found as well, so those roamed here too. "The miners and museum technicians also brought up some three thousand fish fossils from depths of 322 and 356 metres, two crocodile species (a large and a small one), turtles, a salamander, insects, plant remains and pollen — and the pollen is new, because here we see the very beginnings of flowering plants."
The iguanodon first shown to the public in 1883 now stands, together with eight other near-complete specimens, in the glass cage of the Institute of Natural Sciences. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
The iguanodon first shown to the public in 1883 now stands, together with eight other near-complete specimens, in the glass cage of the Institute of Natural Sciences. (Photo: Thierry Hubin, Institute of Natural Sciences)
125 million years ago. In the Early Cretaceous, Europe is an archipelago. And Pangaea has long since broken apart into Laurasia (North America plus Eurasia) and Gondwana (including Africa and South America). (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
125 million years ago. In the Early Cretaceous, Europe is an archipelago. And Pangaea has long since broken apart into Laurasia (North America plus Eurasia) and Gondwana (including Africa and South America). (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
In the Early Cretaceous, Europe had already drifted well past the Tropic of Cancer and, with rising sea levels, had become an archipelago. Bernissart lay on one of the islands — the Anglo–Brabant Massif (encompassing England and Flanders) — which transitioned into the Ardennes Massif and the Rhenish Slate Plateau (western Germany). Iguanodons could migrate from one end to the other, though those of Bernissart apparently were not particularly adventurous (see boxout at the end). On the Isle of Wight in England, besides iguanodons (even a recently discovered iguanodon with a back sail), pterosaurs (Wightia) and carnivorous dinosaurs (Neovenator, Vectiraptor, Eotyrannus and Baryonyx) have also been found. We can safely assume that they, too, lived in the wider region of Bernissart.
Artistic impression of the swamp of Bernissart. (Illustration: Vinciane Decamps - Vinch Atelier). The Planeet België posters are available for purchase (A2 format).
Artistic impression of the swamp of Bernissart. (Illustration: Vinciane Decamps - Vinch Atelier). The Planeet België posters are available for purchase (A2 format).
How so many iguanodons met their end at Bernissart has occupied many a palaeontologist's thoughts. Godefroit explains the most recent scenario. "The region is a karst landscape, dotted with sinkholes. Through the dissolution of rocks deep underground, everything above subsided. This happened gradually. At the surface, a doline first formed — a depression that filled with water. A perfect lake or marsh for a thirsty herd of iguanodons, you might think. But the edges of the doline are unstable. The four-tonne animals may have slipped into the lake or marsh and been unable to get back out. On top of that, they may have been asphyxiated by a well-known and highly lethal marsh gas, hydrogen sulphide or H₂S, produced by bacteria on the lake bed. This tragic scenario may have played out several times."
They died suddenly and must afterwards have been rapidly covered by sediment, as the bones show no signs of scavenging. The clay layers containing the iguanodon fossils then sank through the unstable subsoil, deeper and deeper, until they reached the coal strata of the Carboniferous. The rest is history.
The sinkhole (cran) of Bernissart. The Cretaceous sank into the Carboniferous.
The sinkhole (cran) of Bernissart. The Cretaceous sank into the Carboniferous.
Or is there still a future? "In the drill cores taken in 2002 and 2003, we could see bone fragments. But reopening a flooded coal mine costs a fortune."
The Cretaceous period is best known for its final phase, with T. rex, Velociraptor, Triceratops and the duck-billed dinosaurs or hadrosaurs. These last were descendants of the iguanodontians and possessed a remarkable battery of teeth for grinding plant matter. All those iconic dinosaurs are found mainly in North America and China. From our country, only a few dinosaur finds are known from the Late Cretaceous: a tooth from a ceratopsid-like dinosaur, Craspedodon, found in Lonzée, and in the area around Eben-Emael two birds still encased in stone, Asteriornis and Janavis, as well as some bone remains of theropods and hadrosaurs.
No wonder we find so few Late Cretaceous dinosaurs: Belgium was at that time almost entirely submerged. Ammonites, sea urchins, shellfish, but above all tiny algae with calcium skeletons (coccoliths) settled on the sea floor after death and over time built up thick packages of chalk. Fossil hunters can have a nice field day at the white cliffs of the Opal Coast and of Dover. In our country, those chalk packages lie buried deep, but in the area around Maastricht they come to the surface. There are marl caves — kilometres of carved passages through a hill of chalk — and open quarries such as Sint-Pietersberg (the former ENCI quarry). There, magnificent skeletons of mosasaurs — literally Meuse lizards — have been found. They stood at the top of the food chain in the Cretaceous seas and are sometimes called Sea Rexes.
70 million years ago. In the Late Cretaceous, our regions are predominantly covered by sea. The Atlantic Ocean grows and drives a wedge between North America and Europe, and between South America and Africa. (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
70 million years ago. In the Late Cretaceous, our regions are predominantly covered by sea. The Atlantic Ocean grows and drives a wedge between North America and Europe, and between South America and Africa. (C.R. Scotese and GPlates)
But the reign of all those land and sea reptiles came to an end 66 million years ago when an asteroid the size of Brussels struck near Yucatán in Mexico, blasting out a crater as large as Belgium. A recent study by the VUB and the Royal Observatory of Belgium modelled the consequences in the minutes and years following impact. Palaeontologist Pim Kaskes and colleagues sampled in North Dakota the millimetre-thin layer formed by the settling dust.
"They are astonishingly fine silicate grains. Using a mathematical model, we calculated that within days of the impact the entire world was enveloped in a cloud of fine particles. It hung there for as long as 15 years and cooled the Earth by 15 degrees Celsius. For two years, virtually no solar radiation penetrated the thick shroud of dust, and photosynthesis ground to a halt. The knock-on effect on both land and marine life was catastrophic."
Pim Kaskes (VUB, Natural History Museum London), Cem Berk Senel (Royal Observatory of Belgium) and Johan Vellekoop (KU Leuven, Institute of Natural Sciences) during the sampling of the K-Pg boundary in North Dakota. (Photo: Maria Stuut)
Pim Kaskes (VUB, Natural History Museum London), Cem Berk Senel (Royal Observatory of Belgium) and Johan Vellekoop (KU Leuven, Institute of Natural Sciences) during the sampling of the K-Pg boundary in North Dakota. (Photo: Maria Stuut)
Tip! Watch the poetic documentary 'On the day the sunlight disappeared' by Maria and Frederik Stuut on VRT MAX.X.
All animals larger than a dog went extinct during this period. Organisms that could go without food for a time stood a better chance of surviving the brief but violent catastrophe: animals that lived in burrows or could enter a state of dormancy, as well as animals that were not fussy about their diet. And plants with seeds. Of the dinosaurs, only a limited number of feathered species made it through. They are the ancestors of the 11,000 bird species alive today.
To see the so-called Cretaceous–Palaeogene boundary, we need not travel to Mexico or the United States. On virtually every continental area of that time, a thin layer of iridium has been found — a substance found mainly in meteorites.
And if you walk a kilometre through the beige passages of the marl cave at Geulhemmerberg, near Maastricht, you reach walls marked by a few dark grey clay streaks. Nothing remarkable, you would think - until you know what they are. "This is in all likelihood the effect in our region of the meteorite impact in Mexico," says geologist Johan Vellekoop (KU Leuven, Institute of Natural Sciences), as we stand before the wall and press our fingers into the still-damp lines of clay. "That violent event, 66 million years ago, completely churned up our sea floor, with that subsequent deposition of clay — which you normally find deeper out at sea or in lagoons. Did the meteorite impact trigger a tsunami that rolled all the way here? Or did the climate change cause storms? There are many hypotheses."
The effect of the asteroid impact in Mexico on our regions. Are we looking at the consequences of tsunamis or of violent storms? (Photo: Reinout Verbeke, Institute of Natural Sciences)
The effect of the asteroid impact in Mexico on our regions. Are we looking at the consequences of tsunamis or of violent storms? (Photo: Reinout Verbeke, Institute of Natural Sciences)
The most important layer for us mammals: the K-Pg boundary. Above the dark grey clay layers, no tyranny of dinosaurs anymore, and our moment has arrived. (Photo: Siska Van Parys, Institute of Natural Sciences)
The most important layer for us mammals: the K-Pg boundary. Above the dark grey clay layers, no tyranny of dinosaurs anymore, and our moment has arrived. (Photo: Siska Van Parys, Institute of Natural Sciences)
I glow with excitement, standing before the marker line that heralds a new era: the Cenozoic — 'the age of new life'. A millimetre below the clay layer, the tyranny of mosasaurs and T. rexes still reigns; a little above that dark grey historical boundary, an unknown primate ancestor of ours is crawling through the dust...
3D ATLAS OF THE IGUANODONS
In the past two years, stroboscopic flashes of light could regularly be seen inside the glass enclosure of the Iguanodons of Bernissart (watch the video). Researcher Christophe Mallet and colleagues removed the bones one by one from their nineteenth-century metal mounts and passed a handheld scanner over each one. They now have many terabytes of 3D images, from skull to smallest toe bone. These virtual copies, which can be zoomed in on almost endlessly, are expected to inspire new studies in the coming years. But Mallet has already found something remarkable. "Above the eye sits a bone — the postorbital — and I established that among 13 individuals whose postorbital is preserved, there are two distinct forms: one shaped like a hockey stick, and one with a beautiful arch. Could this indicate a difference between females and males?"
3D model of Iguanodon Bernissartensis by Christophe Mallet (Instituut voor Natuurwetenschappen)
3D model of Iguanodon Bernissartensis by Christophe Mallet (Instituut voor Natuurwetenschappen)
Another recent study examined, among other things, the strontium and oxygen isotopes in the teeth, bones and tendons (yes, those were fossilised too). The oxygen isotopes tell us about the quantity and temperature of the water the animals drank. It turns out that winters were cold and wet, and summers warm and dry. Strontium, meanwhile, is absorbed through food (in this case plants). The isotopic composition reflects the geology of the soil on which those plants grew. The researchers were thus able to conclude that our well-known iguanodons were not herds that had migrated from England, Germany or elsewhere, but that they grazed locally their entire lives. The Iguanodons of Bernissart turn out to be genuinely… from Bernissart. They met their terrible end — drowning and/or suffocation by a sulphur gas — in their native region. If that is any consolation.
The Institute of Natural Sciences is reconstructing the wanderings of the patch of land we know today as Belgium: from the South Pole to the place where we're located today. A series on our country's unique geology in five longreads, five podcast episodes (in Dutch) and five posters.
Every two months in 2026 a new episode will appear on
www.naturalsciences.be/r/planetbelgium
With support from the Wernaers Fund of FNRS.
A heartfelt thanks to, among others:
- Geologist Kris Piessens (Institute of Natural Sciences) for inspiration and guidance
- Geologist Michiel Dusar (Institute of Natural Sciences) for reviewing
- Sound designer Joris Van Damme and musician Bart Couvreur for the podcast
- Illustrator Vinciane Decamps (Vinch Atelier) for the posters
- Videomaker Stijn Pardon (Institute of Natural Sciences) for the trailer
